A Think Again Media Group publication
Money Stumper

Birth certificates and Treasury accounts

Birth certificate bonds and the borrowing of official names

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Money Stumper

Birth certificate bonds and the borrowing of official names

Birth certificate bonds were described in the IRS's March 2022 survey as part of a redemption theory about nonexistent Treasury accounts. The theory treated a person's birth record as a financial asset belonging to a separate, government-controlled identity. Promoters attached supposed balances to that identity and represented homemade documents as claims against Treasury funds. The IRS rejected the account theory and described Form 1099-OID as an information return rather than a payment instrument. The agency also summarized United States v. Anderson, a 2003 decision stating that Treasury maintained no individual depository accounts against which such instruments could be drawn.

One earlier civil case concerned Lowell and Bessie Weldon. In October 2008, the United States sued in the Eastern District of California to reduce federal tax assessments to judgment and foreclose liens on three parcels of real property. The assessments covered Lowell Weldon's tax years 1997 through 2003. Bessie Weldon was included because of her community-property interest. They attended an initial scheduling conference but did not subsequently respond to the complaint, despite service of court documents. The court entered a default judgment and foreclosure order on March 30, 2010.

In seeking to reopen the judgment, the Weldons characterized themselves as creditors entitled to redeem their liabilities against their personal value. The court analyzed that claim as redemption or charge-back theory. Its May 4, 2010, order discussed the theory's supposed conversion of citizens into assets and its treatment of birth certificates as Treasury-backed property. The court rejected the theory as meritless and denied the motions. It also accepted the government's argument that reopening would permit continued tax evasion involving fraudulent materials. Notice of the lawsuit and intentional nonresponse supplied further grounds for leaving the judgment in place.

Birth certificate bonds also appeared in the reasoning of an Idaho injunction case against Penny Lea Jones, formerly Penny Lea Wardrop. The United States filed its complaint in October 2009 concerning her return-preparation business in Shelley. The district court entered a preliminary injunction on January 15, 2010. In a July 7, 2011, order, it described the underlying theory as treating each newborn's certificate as a security representing future labor. That was the theory advanced in the litigation, not a finding that the certificates were securities. Jones had prepared more than 400 fraudulent returns.

The court examined individual customers' records as well as the broader theory. Kenneth and Patricia Malinowski's 1999 return reported $411,883 in interest income; most was attributed to attached forms supposedly documenting discount interest. The IRS had no record of receiving those forms from any entity on the couple's behalf. The court found repeated violations and concluded that a narrower restriction would not prevent continued interference with tax administration. It granted summary judgment and permanently barred Jones from preparing federal returns for others, alongside restrictions on promoting the false Treasury-account claims.

A Missouri prosecution concerned an attempted payment to the Social Security Administration. Charles Daniel Koss received a demand on April 15, 2010, to repay $212,768 in disability benefits obtained while his work went unreported. About a month later, he mailed a document labeled Registered Private Money Order, purporting to draw on a Treasury trust account. The Justice Department's account of the trial states that the account did not exist. Koss told investigators that he had studied redemption theory, which attributed secret accounts to fictitious identities corresponding to newborn citizens.

Koss had founded Embassy Mortgage in Blue Springs in 1994. Witnesses described him working full-time as a loan officer and operating the business during the period when he received disability payments. On February 27, 2013, the Justice Department announced guilty verdicts on two theft counts and counts of disability fraud, mail fraud, and transmitting a false negotiable instrument with intent to defraud the government. The investigation involved the Social Security Administration's inspector general, Treasury's tax-administration inspector general, and the Postal Inspection Service.

Birth certificate bonds reached a different institutional setting in the 2024 bankruptcy of Claudette O. Henry. On August 6, trustee Kathleen Steil reported that the estate had no property available for distribution beyond exempt property. Henry objected that her birth certificate had been overlooked as an asset capable of offsetting obligations. On August 20, Judge Paul W. Bonapfel of the Northern District of Georgia overruled the objection and denied a hearing request. He held that the certificate had no financial value and was not an estate asset that could be collected and converted to money.

The order distinguished the certificate's role as a vital record from the claimed monetary asset. It also cited TreasuryDirect's warning about supposed Exemption Accounts and bonds allegedly held by the government. The warning, reproduced in a footnote, rejected claims that birth certificates financed purchases or accessed those supposed savings bonds. The court cited earlier federal decisions rejecting certificates as redeemable instruments.

The Question

Does a record of birth create a hidden Treasury account that its holder can use to clear debts?

Show the answer

The Answer

A birth certificate does not create a secret Treasury account or bond. TreasuryDirect says the supposed Exemption Account does not exist in the Treasury system.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Money Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.