Bank of Amsterdam: the ledger that replaced worn coin
The Bank of Amsterdam, known in Dutch as the Wisselbank, opened on 31 January 1609, according to Wikipedia. It was vouched for by the city of Amsterdam, and Wikipedia calls it the first public bank to offer accounts that could not be turned directly into coin. The money in those accounts was called bank money, and the story of why anyone wanted it starts with a pile of bad coins.
Adam Smith, writing in The Wealth of Nations in 1776, describes the trouble. Amsterdam's trade drew in clipped and worn foreign coin from all over Europe. Smith says that before 1609 this reduced the value of the city's currency by about nine per cent below good money fresh from the mint. Good coin that appeared was melted down or carried away, and merchants with plenty of currency could not always find enough good money to settle their bills of exchange. Wikipedia adds that some 500 different coins, legal or illegal, circulated, with no good system for working out exchange rates.
The answer of the Bank of Amsterdam was a ledger. Smith says it took foreign coin and the light, worn coin of the country at its real intrinsic value in good standard money, less a small deduction for coinage and management, and gave the depositor a credit in its books. That credit was bank money. Smith adds that the city ruled that all bills drawn on or arranged at Amsterdam for 600 guilders and upward be paid in bank money. Every merchant therefore needed an account, and payment became a transfer in the books, with no counting of coins and no carrying of them from one place to another.
Smith also notes the bank money carried a premium over the current money of the city, which he calls the agio and puts at about five per cent in his day. He reports that some people explained the premium by the bank keeping its money always below the demand for it, and he calls that account in great measure chimerical. Wikipedia describes the same agio as a premium of bank guilders over circulating guilders and says that from 1683 it floated within a band set by supply and demand.
Gold and silver bars could be deposited too. Smith says the Bank of Amsterdam gave a credit about five per cent below the mint price of the metal and issued a receipt, which let the bearer take the bullion back within six months by returning the same amount of bank money and paying a keeping charge. The claim slip and the bank credit were bought and sold separately. Smith calls the bank the great warehouse of Europe for bullion. Wikipedia reports that the number of account holders grew from 708 to 1,202 between 1611 and 1620, and reached 2,918 in 1721, the highest in two centuries of banking.
The Bank of Amsterdam was run by commissioners chosen by the city council. Smith adds that the four reigning burgomasters, changed every year, visited the treasure, compared it with the books and handed it over on oath to their successors. He writes that in 1672, when the French king was at Utrecht, the bank paid out so readily that no doubt remained about its good faith, and that some of the pieces brought out were scorched from a fire in the town house soon after the bank was founded.
Here the two sources part. Smith says the bank professed to lend out no part of what was deposited, and that at Amsterdam no point of faith was better established than that every guilder of bank money had a guilder of gold or silver behind it. He adds that nothing but conjecture could be offered about the size of the treasure and puts it at about 33,000,000 guilders. Wikipedia says the full-reserve policy relaxed over time. It says the bank lent large sums to the city and to the Dutch East India Company, and that this stayed confidential until it became public knowledge by July 1790.
The accounts of the end differ in tone but agree on the outline. Wikipedia says the Dutch East India Company defaulted on large advances during the Fourth Anglo-Dutch War and that confidence never recovered. By 1790 the premium on bank money had faded to almost nothing, and the Bank of Amsterdam declared itself insolvent. The city took over direct control in 1791. In March 1795 the new city council published the bank's unfavorable balance sheet, which broke two centuries of secrecy. In 1802, according to Wikipedia, its liabilities were again entirely backed by specie. The Nederlandsche Bank was founded in 1814, and the Wisselbank went into liquidation in 1819.
Historians do not agree on how to label it. Wikipedia says it has been described by some as the first true central bank, though the view is not shared by everyone, and it notes that unlike the Bank of England it neither managed the national currency nor acted as a lender except to the government in emergencies. Wikipedia also cites economists Stephen Quinn and William Roberds, who see in its history lessons about a bank that pursued stable money while building up claims on weak debtors.
Smith's picture of 1776 and Wikipedia's picture of the 1790s describe the same institution at different moments, and they cannot both be read as the whole. The record shows a ledger that began as a cure for worn coin, became a warehouse for bullion, and ended as a lender whose loans had become public knowledge by July 1790.
- Wikipedia, Bank of Amsterdam — en.wikipedia.org
- Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations, Book IV chapter 3, Project Gutenberg — www.gutenberg.org