The paper money motto: why 1864, 1955, 1956 and 1957 differ
The paper money motto first appeared in 1957 on $1 silver certificates. The Bureau of Engraving and Printing identifies Series 1957 as the first paper issue carrying “In God We Trust.” Coins had carried the words much earlier. The intervening dates mark different decisions: authorizing coin designs, directing an inscription onto currency, adopting a national motto, and producing notes through a new printing process.
A Treasury history reproduced in a 2011 House Judiciary Committee report traces an early appeal to November 13, 1861. The Reverend M.R. Watkinson wrote to Treasury Secretary Salmon P. Chase seeking religious recognition on American coins. Chase asked Mint Director James Pollock to prepare a suitable design. Existing legislation prescribed the devices and inscriptions on coins, so Treasury's design discussions also required congressional authority before a new inscription could circulate.
The wording developed through revision. In December 1863, Pollock submitted proposed designs for one-cent, two-cent, and three-cent coins. His suggested inscriptions referred to country and God, or God and trust. Chase responded with changes, including the familiar phrase for the design bearing a shield. The inscription emerged from exchanges between the Mint and Treasury before it became a familiar feature of American money.
The House report places the motto's first appearance on the two-cent coin in 1864. It identifies another law in 1865 allowing the Mint director, with Treasury approval, to use the inscription on additional gold and silver coins. Several gold and silver denominations, along with the nickel three-cent piece, received it beginning in 1866. Adoption therefore advanced through particular designs and denominations over time.
The original act of April 22, 1864 supplies the material setting. Congress specified a cent weighing 48 grains and composed of 95 percent copper, with the remaining 5 percent consisting of tin and zinc in proportions determined by the Mint director. The new two-cent piece was to have the same composition and weigh 96 grains. The inscription belonged to a law that also determined the physical substance of the coins. Its significance as a design change accompanied a change in what the Mint was authorized to manufacture.
The act's continuation assigned the coins' shape, mottoes, and devices to the Mint director, subject to the Treasury secretary's approval. It also required regulations to keep weights and alloy proportions consistent, with periodic trials by the Mint assayer and written reports. Those provisions placed artistic and technical decisions within an administrative process. Congress established the framework, Treasury approved designs, and the Mint had responsibility for producing coins that met the required physical specifications.
The paper money motto entered federal printing legislation through a separate law approved July 11, 1955. Congress directed that new currency-printing dies carry the inscription when adopted as part of Treasury's program to increase press capacity at the BEP. The Treasury secretary could choose an appropriate location on those dies. The statute connected the wording to an equipment program already under way. Its reference to the adoption of new dies also explains the interval between the law's approval and the first paper issue bearing the words. The legislative instruction established a process for incorporating the inscription into production.
The joint resolution approved July 30, 1956 performed another function. Public Law 84-851 declared “In God we trust” the national motto of the United States. Its brief text did not set out the printing-die arrangements contained in the previous year's act. The two measures followed different timetables: the printing instruction became law in 1955 and the national-motto resolution in 1956. Their different language reflects the different work each measure did. One concerned the status of the phrase; the other concerned its appearance during currency production.
The BEP's chronology connects the first paper appearance with high-speed rotary presses and dry intaglio printing in 1957. Eliminating the wetting stage removed the associated paper distortion and allowed sheets to increase from 18 notes to 32. Series 1957 silver certificates were the first notes made through that process. The chronology separately dates the motto's appearance on Federal Reserve notes to Series 1963. Different currency classes and production schedules carried the same inscription into circulation at different times.
The 1955 statute's closing instruction extended the inscription to all United States currency and coins thereafter. Its immediate mechanism, however, was the preparation of new printing dies during the expansion of BEP press capacity. That combination of a broad objective and a specified manufacturing step gave the law both its reach and its practical timetable. The paper money motto's history consequently includes the work of presses, dies, and paper alongside the public decisions that selected the words.
- Bureau of Engraving and Printing, History, 1957 motto and 32-subject-sheet entries — www.bep.gov
- U.S. Congress, Public Law 84-140 (July 11, 1955), 69 Stat. 290, currency inscription provision — www.govinfo.gov
- U.S. Congress, Public Law 84-851 (July 30, 1956), 70 Stat. 732, national-motto resolution — www.govinfo.gov
- U.S. House Judiciary Committee, House Report 112-47 (2011), historical background — www.govinfo.gov
- U.S. Congress, Act of April 22, 1864, 13 Stat. 54, coin composition and denomination provisions — www.govinfo.gov
- U.S. Congress, Act of April 22, 1864, 13 Stat. 55, design approval and alloy testing provisions — www.govinfo.gov