Tulip bulbs: prices on parchment and a market of promises
Tulip bulbs lay behind the Dutch trading boom that collapsed in February 1637. The commodity could remain underground while promises concerning it changed hands. Museum de Zwarte Tulp's later exhibition catalogue describes a progression from flowering plants to bulbs and then to bulbs still in the soil, sometimes resold repeatedly. Surviving drawings preserve the named varieties and price annotations of this trade, while contemporary satire gives its participants a very different appearance.
Jacob Marrel's tulip album in the Rijksmuseum contains eighty-five illustrations on ninety-seven parchment leaves, with twelve leaves left blank. Most openings show four kinds of tulip, two on each page, accompanied by insects, shells, berries or other flowers. Some leaves carry weights and prices for the tulip bulbs. A contemporary handwritten index lists the illustrated varieties by opening. The names and financial annotations tie the painted flowers to identifiable objects of cultivation and exchange. The album is catalogued as RP-T-1950-266, with watercolour and opaque paint among its materials.
The album extends beyond the year of the crash. The museum dates its leaves to 1637, 1639, 1640 and 1645, with one leaf undated. Its handwritten list also exposes a gap: the first opening is missing, and the last three leaves do not appear in the index. The surviving volume combines material from several dates. A price written beside a flower image assigns a value to a particular bulb; it does not itself document a completed payment between a named buyer and seller.
A different kind of arrangement appears in Hans Bollongier's Floral Still Life, signed and dated 1639. Tulips dominate the bouquet alongside anemones, roses and carnations, although the flowers did not all bloom in the same season. The Rijksmuseum's detailed catalogue identifies Semper Augustus at the centre and a Viceroy variety on the left as cultivations associated with Haarlem growers. They occupy an artistic composition: the catalogue notes that the small vase could not have supported such a large bouquet. Tulip bulbs supplied varieties whose appearance could be celebrated in paint after the market's collapse.
The painting has sometimes been interpreted as a reflection on that collapse. In the scholarly catalogue, Gerdien Wuestman treats that connection cautiously. Flowers could signify transience, and the cracked ledge might suggest decay, but the imagery is not specific enough to establish a deliberate reference to the 1637 crisis. The signed painting and the later interpretation occupy different evidential levels. Its date, varieties and composition are documented; a precise economic message remains uncertain.
Flora's Mallewagen, a print dated 1637 and attributed to Crispijn van de Passe II, makes its satire more explicit. Flora rides in a vehicle driven by a sail, surrounded by figures representing vain hope, greed, gluttony and other failings. Men and women behind it abandon their old occupations to join the passengers. Named tulips lie on the ground. In the background, a farmer from Zandvoort and a local official watch the vehicle swallowed by waves. A small scene in one corner places Haarlem flower dealers around a table. The print, catalogued as RP-P-OB-77.710, also had an accompanying text sheet.
That engraving gives the trade in tulip bulbs a moral cast through its figures and impending wreck. The people leaving their occupations belong to a satirical scene. They are evidence of how the trade was portrayed, rather than a census of everyone who participated. The named flowers and the Haarlem meeting connect the attack to identifiable features of the contemporary flower business. Its warning operates through personifications and visual exaggeration, while Marrel's album supplies individual flower images with names, weights and occasional prices.
The 2023 exhibition catalogue adds a caution about celebrated sums. Its description identifies a highest bid of 4,200 guilders for a Viceroy bulb in February 1637 and says the amount was probably never paid. It also leaves the immediate cause of the collapse uncertain. A high bid, an agreed future purchase and money actually transferred therefore represent different stages of a transaction. The market for tulip bulbs could generate impressive figures even when the plant remained in the ground and the eventual payment was unsettled.
Historian Anne Goldgar's archival research adds the relationships among the participants. Speaking to Smithsonian Magazine in 2017, she described a much smaller trading circle and more limited economic repercussions than the familiar picture of nationwide ruin. She said she had found nobody whose bankruptcy could be traced in her research. The collapse still strained trust: buyers who had agreed to high prices refused to pay, and courts were reluctant to intervene. In a business dependent on personal commitments, repudiated promises carried social consequences. Her interpretation draws on later archival work, distinct from the contemporary albums, paintings and satirical prints through which the flowers and their trade survive.
- Rijksmuseum, Jacob Marrel, tulip album RP-T-1950-266, 1637–1645 — dated leaves, index, weights and prices — www.rijksmuseum.nl
- Rijksmuseum, Hans Bollongier, Floral Still Life, 1639, SK-A-799 — object record and scholarly catalogue by Gerdien Wuestman — www.rijksmuseum.nl
- Rijksmuseum, Flora’s Mallewagen, 1637, attributed to Crispijn van de Passe II, RP-P-OB-77.710 — www.rijksmuseum.nl
- Henk Looijesteijn / Museum de Zwarte Tulp, Tulip fever, 2023 exhibition catalogue — catalogue description and back-cover text held by Rijksmuseum — www.rijksmuseum.nl
- Lorraine Boissoneault, Smithsonian Magazine, There Never Was a Real Tulip Fever, 18 September 2017 — interview with Anne Goldgar — www.smithsonianmag.com