A Think Again Media Group publication
Money Stumper

Canada's penny withdrawal

Canadian penny: the last coin and the long withdrawal

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Money Stumper

Canadian penny: the last coin and the long withdrawal

The last Canadian penny has a museum number: NCC 2012.42.1. The Bank of Canada Museum identifies it as the coin struck when Finance Minister Jim Flaherty operated the press at the Royal Canadian Mint's Winnipeg facility on May 4, 2012. Its place in the museum's permanent gallery preserves a specific manufacturing event. The press stopped making pennies months before the distribution system stopped supplying them. Those two endings, one attached to an individual object and the other to a nationwide stock of coins, happened on different dates.

The museum's collection also preserves a 1982 cent, NCC 1983.47.14, from the period when the penny had twelve sides. Its historical explanation connects that shape with efforts to distinguish cents from nickels by touch for blind and partially sighted people. The last penny belonged to a denomination whose size, shape and materials had repeatedly changed. Ending production was a further change in the physical currency, while the cent itself continued as a unit in which prices were expressed.

The Mint stopped distributing pennies on February 4, 2013. The withdrawal brought cash rounding to the nearest five-cent increment, while non-cash payments could retain exact-cent settlement. Rounding concerned the final cash amount, rather than separately changing every item in a purchase. The Canadian penny withdrawal therefore left a distinction between a price recorded in cents and the coins used to settle it. The cent continued as a unit of account after the Mint stopped supplying one-cent pieces to the circulation system.

The Mint's historical explanation identifies several reasons for the change: manufacturing expenses above face value, coins accumulating in households, environmental considerations, and the cost of handling the denomination throughout the economy. The government's estimated annual saving was $11 million, a forecast also recorded by the Bank of Canada Museum. Withdrawal ended distribution of the coins without removing their legal-tender status. The surviving pieces consequently belonged to an older circulating stock whose manufacture had ended, while institutions faced the practical work of gathering large quantities of small metal objects.

The Mint's Annual Report 2012 gives the production problem a precise scale. Rising labour, metal, manufacturing and distribution expenses had pushed the cost of each penny to 1.6 cents. Its operating discussion records both the final May 2012 strike and the February 2013 distribution cutoff, while noting that the coins would remain legal tender. In those records, the Canadian penny's retirement was a decision about the cost of sustaining a denomination whose individual face value was smaller than the expense of making it.

Commemoration went ahead alongside withdrawal. The annual report records a miniature pure-gold coin, a selectively gold-plated silver coin, a five-ounce silver coin and a five-coin silver set illustrating changing penny designs. It says the commemorative penny products sold out. The report's design chronology includes G. E. Kruger-Gray's maple-leaf twig, used from 1937 with the exception of Alex Colville's flying rock dove in 1967. The farewell products preserved designs associated with circulating cents through a separate series of collectible objects.

The Mint's specification sheet documents how little of a late Canadian penny was actually copper. For the steel composition introduced in 2000, it lists 94 percent steel, 1.5 percent nickel and 4.5 percent copper plating. Weight was 2.35 grams and diameter 19.05 millimetres. Its accompanying note says cents could also be made with the copper-plated zinc composition used from 1997: 98.4 percent zinc and 1.6 percent copper plating. A copper-coloured surface therefore covered different underlying materials within the same denomination.

The mintage figures on that sheet record 662,750,000 cents for 2011 and 199,347,000 for 2012. Even the final, shortened production year contributed nearly 200 million pieces. Those annual manufacturing totals measure coins made, while the later recovery totals measure coins returned. Their different purposes matter because the withdrawal involved a stock accumulated across many years, including cents with different compositions, rather than simply the removal of the last year's output.

In its 2022 retrospective, the Mint estimated that 6 billion pennies had been in circulation when withdrawal was announced. More than 3.5 billion returned in the first year alone. Recovering the Canadian penny meant moving material as well as changing settlement practices: the Mint described more than 14 million kilograms transported in 1,200 tractor-trailer trips. Coin deposits surged to five times annual levels after the announcement and did not return to normal until late 2013.

The Mint credited existing relationships with financial institutions, armoured-car companies and its metal processor, supported by a digital platform, with making that recovery manageable. Anthony Rotondo, its senior manager for Canadian circulation, described adapting established infrastructure to the new task. The last strike left a single cent in a museum. The subsequent operation gathered billions of older pieces through banks and transport networks, recovering their metal after their role in everyday change had diminished.

The Question

Which Canadian payments are rounded following the penny's withdrawal?

Show the answer

The Answer

Cash payments are rounded to the nearest five cents. Rounding applies to the total rather than each item, while non-cash transactions such as credit-card payments can still be settled to the exact cent.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Money Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.