A Think Again Media Group publication
Money Stumper

How much would you put on the first monthly Social Security check?

Ida May Fuller and the first monthly Social Security check

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Money Stumper

Ida May Fuller and the first monthly Social Security check

Ida May Fuller was a 65-year-old retired legal secretary in Ludlow, Vermont, when she found a check for $22.54 in her mailbox in February 1940. It was dated January 31, 1940, and it was the first monthly retirement payment the United States government made under Social Security. The program had been enacted five years earlier, in the middle of the Great Depression.

President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed the Social Security Act on August 14, 1935, at about 3:30 p.m. on a Wednesday, according to the Social Welfare History Project's chronology. The law was part of the New Deal. It provided for payments to retirees over 65 who had paid payroll taxes and for compensation to the unemployed. The Springfield-Greene County Library's account adds that payroll taxes were split evenly between worker and employer, and that the money from current workers financed payments to current retirees.

The taxes began before the checks did. On January 1, 1937, employers and employees became subject to a tax of one percent of wages on up to $3,000 a year, and workers began earning credits toward old-age insurance benefits. Lump-sum payments also became payable that day to eligible workers, their survivors or their estates. From 1937 until 1940, a law firm's summary of Social Security's own account explains, the program paid benefits as a single lump sum. These payments were meant to give some payback to contributors who would not stay in the program long enough to qualify for monthly benefits. The average lump sum in that period was $58.06. The earliest reported applicant was Ernest Ackerman, a Cleveland motorman who retired one day after the program began. A nickel had been withheld from his pay, and he received 17 cents.

Under the 1935 law, monthly benefits were not supposed to begin until 1942. The interval was meant to build up the trust funds and to set a minimum period of participation. Amendments dated August 10, 1939, moved the start of monthly payments up to 1940 and broadened the program to include benefits for dependents and survivors. That change put January 1940 on the calendar and made Fuller's check possible. The monthly benefits that began that month were authorized for aged retired workers, their aged wives or widows, children under 18 and surviving aged parents.

Ida May Fuller was born in 1874 on a farm outside Ludlow, according to HISTORY. She was a descendant of Mayflower passengers. She worked as a schoolteacher for about 12 years, then attended business school and spent 24 years as a legal secretary at a Ludlow law firm before retiring in November 1939. Shortly afterward she went to the Social Security office in nearby Rutland. She later said, "It wasn't that I expected anything, mind you," but she knew she had been paying into the program and wanted to ask about it. A little over two months after she applied, the check arrived, numbered 00-000-001. She did not notice the number. "I just cashed it. I wanted the money," she said, and she did not learn she had received the first benefit payment until five years later.

The check was worth slightly less than what she had paid in. She had put $24.75 into payroll taxes in the three years before she retired, and her first check came to $22.54. Over the following 35 years she received $22,888.92 in benefits, about 924 times her contributions. She never married or had children, collected more than 400 monthly checks and died in 1975 at age 100. When Social Security was enacted, average life expectancy was 64 for American women and 60 for men, so she outlived the figures the program was built around by a wide margin.

Ida May Fuller was an unlikely poster child for the New Deal. Vermont was one of two states that voted against Roosevelt in 1936, and HISTORY describes Fuller as a lifelong Republican who favored limited government. She had been a high school classmate of President Calvin Coolidge, and the partners in the law firm where she worked included a former Republican Vermont governor and Coolidge's attorney general. Her checks supplemented income from renting out a room and selling vegetables from her garden.

Ida May Fuller's own comments on later raises show how she saw the program. In 1950, Congress raised her monthly check from $22.54 to $41.30. She said, "You can't live on it of course if you've got other expenses to pay, but it's a help." In 1954 she supported a raise proposed by President Dwight D. Eisenhower and said she would use the extra money "to paint my house." In 1970 she opposed another increase, saying it "ought to go" no higher, because raises burdened working people who pay in.

By the numbers the program had grown quickly. The Springfield-Greene County Library reports that total benefits paid were $35 million in 1940 and $961 million in 1950. Fuller's check was the first of those payments, and the start of the monthly system that replaced the early lump sums.

The Question

How much was Ida May Fuller's first monthly Social Security benefit check in 1940?

Show the answer

The Answer

$22.54.

The check dated January 31, 1940 went to a retired legal secretary in Vermont. Fuller reached this historic place through an ordinary visit to ask about benefits, and her claim became the first entry on the first payment list.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Money Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.