The Freedman's Bank had a charter but no federal guarantee
The Freedman's Bank carried the authority of a congressional charter, and many of its depositors believed that meant the government stood behind their savings. It did not. Writing in the National Archives magazine Prologue, Reginald Washington states that, contrary to what many depositors were led to believe, the bank's assets were not protected by the federal government. When the Freedman's Bank closed on June 29, 1874, the losses fell on tens of thousands of formerly enslaved people and their families.
The bank began as a plan to protect soldiers' pay. Prologue records that on January 27, 1865, John W. Alvord, a Congregational minister and abolitionist, met in New York with more than twenty philanthropists and business leaders. He told them that many Black soldiers receiving back pay and enlistment bounties had no safe place to keep their money, and proposed a benevolent savings bank. Military savings banks already existed: in 1864 General Rufus Saxton had created one at Beaufort, South Carolina, and General Benjamin Butler another at Norfolk, Virginia.
Congress acted quickly. With the help of Senator Charles Sumner of Massachusetts, a bill to incorporate the Freedman's Savings and Trust Company came before Congress on February 13, 1865, and President Abraham Lincoln signed it into law on March 3, 1865. The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency notes that Congress created the Freedmen's Bureau on the same day. The charter directed investment in "stocks, bonds, Treasury notes, or other securities of the United States," while allowing an available fund of up to one-third of deposits to meet current payments. A board of 50 trustees would manage the bank, with its books open to inspection by persons Congress appointed.
Growth was rapid. By 1871, the National Archives records guide states, the Freedman's Bank had grown to include 37 branches. During its 9-year history, it served some 70,000 depositors and received more than $57 million in deposits. The OCC notes that most accounts were small, the vast majority between $5 and $50. The bank built a headquarters on Lafayette Square in Washington, at a cost of more than $200,000 to build and furnish.
The reassurance came from the bank's own promotion. Prologue describes how bank advertisements used the names of prominent officials such as Abraham Lincoln and Oliver Otis Howard, often to the point of misleading depositors into believing that their deposits were backed by the federal government. Depositors were reminded at public meetings that the bank held a charter from Congress. The charter placed management in the hands of trustees, who filled vacancies on the board themselves by ballot.
Supervision was the gap. The OCC explains that its examiners supervised national banks and enforced a ban on real estate lending, but the Freedman's Bank charter made it answerable to Congress instead, and that oversight was episodic. After the post-war economy faltered, a new management team persuaded Congress to relax the charter and allow loans backed by real estate. The amendment, approved on May 6, 1870, permitted investment to the extent of one-half in bonds or notes secured by mortgages on real estate worth twice the loan. The OCC adds that Henry Cooke, while on the bank's board, used its assets to benefit his family banking business.
The end came within months of a famous appointment. In March 1874, after runs on several branches, the bank's officials elected Frederick Douglass as president. In his autobiography, Douglass recalled lending the bank $10,000 of his own money to meet what he had been told was a temporary emergency. He said the loan was repaid, although the delay increased his concerns. He later described himself as "married to a corpse" and recounted recommending that the bank close. OCC examiner Charles Meigs had reported on the bank's precarious position in February 1873 and 1874. Congress passed an act on June 20, 1874, and on June 29 the trustees voted to shut the Freedman's Bank down.
The losses were heavy and the repayment partial. The OCC records that the closing left 61,144 depositors with losses of nearly $3 million. Prologue explains that the commissioners and the comptroller of the currency declared five dividend payments between 1875 and 1883, amounting to 62 percent of what was owed. Depositors were asked to mail their passbooks to Washington; those unable to supply passbooks had to complete questionnaires containing the information given when their accounts were opened. Of 61,131 eligible depositors, only 29,996 sent in passbooks, and some 31,000 small depositors never requested their dividends.
The failure left a lasting record of another kind. Because branches collected detailed family information to protect depositors' heirs, Prologue notes, the surviving signature registers list names, birthplaces, occupations, spouses, children and parents, sometimes even former owners and plantations. Those registers, kept by the National Archives in Record Group 101, have become a major source for African American genealogy. A National Park Service history notes that the Treasury Annex later occupied the site of the bank's headquarters. In January 2016, the Treasury Department named the Annex the Freedman's Bank Building.
- National Archives, Prologue: The Freedman's Savings and Trust Company and African American Genealogical Research — www.archives.gov
- Office of the Comptroller of the Currency: The Freedman’s Savings Bank—Good Intentions Were Not Enough; A Noble Experiment Goes Awry — www.occ.gov
- U.S. Statutes at Large, 13 Stat. 510–513: An Act to incorporate the Freedman’s Savings and Trust Company, March 3, 1865 — www.govinfo.gov
- U.S. Statutes at Large, 16 Stat. 119: Amendment to the Freedman’s Savings and Trust Company charter, May 6, 1870 — www.govinfo.gov
- Frederick Douglass, Life and Times of Frederick Douglass, Second Part, Chapter XIV — www.gutenberg.org
- National Archives: The Freedman’s Savings and Trust Company for the District of Columbia, 1865–1874 — www.archives.gov
- National Archives: Black Family Research, Reference Information Paper 108, revised 2010 — www.archives.gov
- National Park Service: The Era of Reconstruction, 1861–1900, page 34, note 83 — home.nps.gov