A Think Again Media Group publication
Money Stumper

IRS collection notices and signatures

Collection due process: signatures and the history behind the notices

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Money Stumper

Collection due process: signatures and the history behind the notices

Collection due process notices were at the center of Oropeza v. Commissioner, a 2008 Tax Court case rejecting a signature objection. The IRS's March 2022 account records the court's holding that the statute imposed no signature requirement on the final notice of intent to levy and notice of hearing rights. The court also imposed a $10,000 penalty for frivolous and groundless arguments, including an objection that the taxpayer had not received IRS agents' pocket commissions.

The statutory setting dated to the Internal Revenue Service Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998, enacted on July 22. Section 3401 added sections 6320 and 6330 to the Internal Revenue Code. One addressed notice and hearings associated with federal tax liens; the other addressed notice and hearings before levy. Congress placed these provisions within a subtitle covering protections for people subject to audit or collection activity. Collection due process became part of a broader restructuring that also addressed IRS management, oversight, employee practices, and electronic filing.

The enacted text assigned hearings to the IRS Office of Appeals and specified an impartial officer without prior involvement in the unpaid tax, unless that condition was waived. It required verification that applicable legal and administrative requirements had been met. The officer's determination also had to consider the issues raised and weigh efficient collection against unnecessary intrusion. Congress provided judicial review, initially divided between the Tax Court and federal district courts according to jurisdiction over the underlying liability. These were components of the system Congress established in 1998.

Earlier collection cases illustrated how courts treated objections to official authority. In Craig v. Commissioner, decided in 2002, the Tax Court held that the Treasury secretary's delegate could issue the final levy notice. The IRS summary identifies a delegation order giving that authority to Automated Collection Branch Chiefs. Tolotti v. Commissioner, also decided in 2002, concerned a federal tax lien notice challenged for lacking certification under Nevada law. The Tax Court upheld it, explaining that federal law controlled its form and content. The Ninth Circuit affirmed Tolotti in 2003.

Thomas Selgas's dispute involved a deficiency notice for 2002 income tax, rather than the collection due process notice considered in Oropeza. On January 16, 2007, the Fifth Circuit affirmed the Tax Court's judgment against Selgas. The notice stated a $23,303 deficiency and a $592.20 delinquency penalty. Selgas challenged the authority of the employee who signed it. The appellate court held that the notice sufficiently conveyed the IRS's determination and the amount, making the disputed signature and the signer's identity unnecessary to its validity.

Selgas also produced purported returns supporting a refund claim. The IRS had no record of receiving them, and the Tax Court did not credit his testimony that he had filed them earlier. The Fifth Circuit left that factual finding undisturbed. It additionally held that the missing taxpayer signatures deprived those returns of legal effect. A further amended return lacked evidence supporting its deductions and other entries. Within the same litigation, the court therefore reached different conclusions about signatures on the government's deficiency notice and on Selgas's own purported returns.

The National Taxpayer Advocate's 2014 report to Congress criticized another aspect of collection due process: the quality of the balancing analysis. Its review of procedures and case law found that Appeals gave insufficient attention to taxpayers' concerns about intrusive enforcement. Formulaic statements that balancing had occurred created the appearance of simply endorsing Collection's earlier decisions. The report connected independent review to Congress's intention that people receive meaningful consideration before the government took property.

The report also recorded the scale of collection administration: in fiscal 2014, Collection filed 535,580 liens and issued 1,995,987 levies. It criticized reliance on Collection's own manual as guidance for Appeals and described earlier recommendations for separate Appeals guidance. Those institutional criticisms concerned how substantive safeguards were administered, alongside the courts' rejection of signature and delegation objections.

A later Supreme Court case concerned access to judicial review. Boechler, a Fargo, North Dakota, law firm, received an IRS discrepancy notice in 2015 and subsequently an intentional-disregard penalty. After a collection due process hearing, Appeals sustained a proposed levy. The firm's Tax Court petition arrived one day after the statutory 30-day deadline. The Tax Court dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, and the Eighth Circuit affirmed.

On April 21, 2022, a unanimous Supreme Court reversed and remanded. Justice Amy Coney Barrett's opinion held that the deadline was not jurisdictional and was subject to equitable tolling, the doctrine permitting exceptions to a deadline in qualifying circumstances. Congress had not clearly linked that time limit to the Tax Court's authority. The Court left whether Boechler qualified for tolling to proceedings on remand. Its decision addressed the meaning of the review deadline, without deciding the underlying penalty dispute.

The Question

Does the lack of a signature alone invalidate an IRS collection due process notice?

Show the answer

The Answer

The notice remains valid. The IRS says there is no requirement for a signature on the collection due process notice in the statute or regulations. The notice still concerns rights to notice and a hearing in the collection process.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Money Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.