Original issue discount: the tax form behind a refund fraud
Original issue discount, as described in the IRS's March 2022 survey of frivolous tax arguments, was interest embedded in a debt obligation issued below its redemption amount. The agency identified Form 1099-OID as the information return for interest from those investments. The agency traced fraudulent uses to an earlier claim about secret Treasury accounts. Promoters substituted mortgage and credit-card balances for investment income and invented corresponding withholding. The IRS rejected both the supposed accounts and the use of the form to settle debts or withdraw Treasury money.
Gerald Poynter's prosecution documented one nationwide operation. On March 13, 2014, U.S. District Judge Brian C. Wimes sentenced him to 13 years in prison and ordered $951,930 in restitution. Poynter, also known as Brother Jerry Love, had pleaded guilty on November 7, 2013, to conspiracy and filing a fraudulent return. The Justice Department reported 284 fraudulent returns submitted between July 2008 and September 2011. They sought approximately $96 million in refunds; the IRS mistakenly paid $3.5 million. The banks and lenders named on the forms had neither paid the claimed interest nor withheld the claimed taxes.
Poynter filed returns electronically from a karate studio in Blue Springs, Missouri. Successful refunds generated fees, sometimes described as donations to his ministry. He recruited at least 44 filers personally and used branch managers to recruit others. Returns for his own clients accounted for at least $25 million in fraudulent claims on 81 returns. He also submitted returns in his own name and relatives' names. A fraudulent claim filed for himself in July 2008 produced a $196,348 refund.
The Eighth Circuit examined original issue discount fraud in United States v. Johnson on July 31, 2015. Kimberly Johnson had attended Poynter's Atlanta seminar in December 2008 and subsequently became an affiliate. Her customer Marian Fine-Kennedy supplied records of $22,500 in disability income without withholding. Johnson's return instead claimed $89,605 in interest income, $87,492 in withholding, and a $61,959 refund. The court held that the evidence supported Johnson's false-claim conviction. Her contract with Fine-Kennedy included a nondisclosure provision carrying a stated $20 million penalty, and Johnson received $4,117 for her services after the refund arrived.
The combined decision also upheld Nkosi Gray's sentence. His eleven false filings sought refunds for tax years 2005 through 2008. The sentencing calculation counted $1,537,897 in intended loss, compared with $278,874 actually paid. Gray disputed counting multiple filings for the same year. The appellate court accepted the inference that he intended to obtain all the requested refunds and affirmed both judgments. Johnson had received 48 months in prison and Gray 60 months.
A separate original issue discount business operated under the name O.I.D. Process. Mark R. Maness, of Spartanburg, South Carolina, pleaded guilty to conspiracy to submit false claims on November 18, 2014. His clients filed approximately 200 returns seeking around $228 million in fraudulent refunds. The business charged a registration fee and took a 20 percent share of refunds that the IRS issued. It maintained a website and held weekly conference calls with clients. The Justice Department described false interest income and false federal withholding as the basis of its refund claims.
On February 27, 2015, U.S. District Judge Susan Illston sentenced Maness to 41 months in prison, followed by 18 months of supervised release. The restitution order was $1,176,668. Maness and his partner had also directed clients' IRS mail to a San Francisco attorney's address to secure receipt of their fees. IRS Criminal Investigation investigated the operation, and prosecutors included Tax Division trial attorney Matthew J. Kluge and Assistant U.S. Attorney Michael G. Pitman.
The Fontana-based Old Quest Foundation supplied another original issue discount prosecution. Its chief executive, Arturo S. Ruiz, was convicted in January 2013 of conspiracy and 41 false-claim counts. Judge Josephine L. Staton imposed a 168-month prison term in September. On December 6, 2013, Ruiz was ordered to pay $2,925,620 in restitution. More than 400 false returns connected with the operation had sought over $250 million. Ruiz's presentations promised access to secret government accounts; fees reached $10,000, with an additional promised donation of 25 percent of any refund.
Operation Stolen Treasures, the IRS investigation behind the case, resulted in the indictment of 55 people in 2011. By the December 2013 announcement, seven defendants had been convicted at trial and 36 had pleaded guilty; other cases remained pending, and one defendant had been acquitted. Investigators found unfiled returns at Old Quest's offices, including one seeking a $6,868,675 refund. Bank records showed approximately $2 million received from customers and erroneously issued refunds. During a September 2009 search, agents also found emails and printed IRS publications warning about the same scheme in Old Quest's offices.
- Internal Revenue Service, The Truth About Frivolous Tax Arguments, Section I (D to E), subsection E.8 (March 2022) — www.irs.gov
- U.S. Department of Justice, KC Man Sentenced to 13 Years for Leading $100 Million Nationwide Tax Fraud Conspiracy (2014) — www.justice.gov
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, United States v. Johnson (2015), decision — www.govinfo.gov
- U.S. Department of Justice, Operator Of O.I.D. Process Sentenced To 41 Months In Prison For $228 Million Fraudulent Tax Refund Scheme (February 27, 2015) — www.justice.gov
- U.S. Department of Justice, Leader Of Quarter-Billion Dollar Tax Fraud Scheme, Already Sentenced To 14 Years, Ordered To Pay $2.9 Million In Restitution (December 6, 2013) — www.justice.gov