A Think Again Media Group publication
Money Stumper

The Fifth Amendment and tax returns

Fifth Amendment: tax forms in four Supreme Court decisions

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Updated · Money Stumper

Fifth Amendment: tax forms in four Supreme Court decisions

The Fifth Amendment did not excuse Sullivan's complete refusal to file a federal income-tax return. His income came wholly or largely from illegal liquor trading, and his conviction concerned the Revenue Act of 1921. On May 16, 1927, the Supreme Court reversed the appellate judgment that had protected his nonfiling. Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes treated the income's unlawful origin and the return requirement as distinct matters. The decision became a starting point for later cases involving very different documents: registration forms aimed at gamblers and ordinary returns used as evidence in a gambling prosecution.

The constitutional text protected a person from being compelled in a criminal case to be a witness against himself. The National Archives' transcription places that clause alongside protections concerning grand juries, repeated prosecution, due process, and compensation for private property taken for public use. Congress proposed the amendments on September 25, 1789; ten were ratified on December 15, 1791. In the proposed resolution, the eventual Fifth Amendment appeared as the seventh proposal because the first two did not enter the original Bill of Rights. The self-incrimination clause named compelled testimony in criminal proceedings, without a separate provision about tax returns.

Sullivan's appellate court had accepted that illegal liquor profits were taxable. Holmes agreed, pointing to statutory language covering income from any business and observing that an earlier qualification, lawful, had disappeared. The Supreme Court rejected extending the Fifth Amendment privilege to submitting no return at all. Yet Holmes expressly reserved what particular information Sullivan might have withheld. The Court also declined to settle a suggested deduction for illegal expenses such as bribery. Its judgment concerned the conviction for total nonfiling, leaving those narrower matters undecided.

In Marchetti v. United States, decided January 29, 1968, the paperwork itself identified a restricted group. The wagering system combined a $50 annual occupational tax with registration on Form 11-C. It sought residence and business addresses and the names and addresses of agents and employees. Payment produced a revenue stamp that had to be displayed at the business or carried by a person without business premises. Revenue offices maintained public lists of those who paid and supplied certified copies to state or local prosecutors. These were concrete routes by which the federal tax system could expose gambling activity to criminal investigation.

Justice John Harlan's opinion treated those risks as substantial. Marchetti had been convicted of conspiracy to evade the occupational tax, failure to pay it, and failure to register. The Court reversed, holding that a proper assertion of the Fifth Amendment privilege barred punishment under those requirements. It did not withdraw the government's power to tax unlawful activity. The constitutional problem concerned the methods used to obtain identifying information from people whose activities were widely criminalized, including under Connecticut law, where Marchetti allegedly operated.

The companion decision, Grosso v. United States, examined another form. Anthony Grosso's conviction included 15 counts involving the wagering excise tax, four occupational-tax counts, and conspiracy. Monthly Form 730 was designed exclusively for the wagering business. The government told the Court that payment without the accompanying return was not accepted. Harlan therefore treated payment and disclosure together when assessing incrimination. Although this excise-tax scheme lacked the occupational tax's express instruction to supply prosecutors with lists, Congress had imposed no explicit restriction on using the information. The opinion recorded that revenue officials had supplied it to prosecuting authorities. Pennsylvania's gambling penalties supplied the criminal setting. The Supreme Court reversed Grosso's judgment, distinguishing his unavoidable disclosure of wagering activity from the income-tax return in Sullivan. The Fifth Amendment analysis depended on what the entire payment procedure disclosed, including the required form, rather than on treating the transfer of money as an isolated act.

Garner v. United States arrived in a different procedural posture in 1976. Roy Garner had filed Form 1040 returns for 1965, 1966, and 1967. His 1965 return described his occupation as professional gambler; all three reported gambling or wagering income. Prosecutors introduced them alongside testimony from other conspirators and telephone records in a case involving inside information on horse races. The returns helped rebut his claim that his relationships with the other participants were innocent. Their evidentiary value arose from information Garner had already supplied.

Justice Lewis Powell's opinion upheld their admission. Garner had made the disclosures without asserting the privilege on the returns, and the Court did not regard them as compelled incrimination in those circumstances. It distinguished the pressure of custodial interrogation and the gambling-specific reporting systems considered in 1968. Ordinary income-tax forms addressed the public generally; they did not select a group inherently suspected of criminal activity. The Supreme Court affirmed the Ninth Circuit's judgment, leaving Garner's returns admissible in the gambling conspiracy prosecution.

The Question

Can the constitutional protection against self-incrimination provide a blanket exemption from filing a federal tax return?

Show the answer

The Answer

The Fifth Amendment leaves the filing requirement in place. The IRS says the courts have consistently held that disclosure of the type of routine financial information required on a tax return does not incriminate an individual.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Money Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.