A Think Again Media Group publication
Money Stumper

What the Suffolk Bank did with New England banknotes

The Suffolk Bank: how Boston kept New England banknotes at face value

By Phil Springer, Editor · Published · Money Stumper

The Suffolk Bank: how Boston kept New England banknotes at face value

Before the Civil War, a banknote from a country bank in New England could lose value simply by travelling to Boston. The Suffolk Bank, a private Boston bank, changed that. Wikipedia describes it as a private clearinghouse bank that exchanged specie or locally backed bank notes for notes from country banks to which city-dwellers could not easily travel to redeem notes.

Wikipedia says the Suffolk Bank received its charter on February 10, 1818, from the Massachusetts General Court, granted to a group of the Boston Associates that included Patrick Tracy Jackson and Daniel Pinckney Parker. It opened for business on April 1 in rented offices on State Street and moved to the corner of State and Kilby Streets on April 17. Wikipedia lists Nathan Appleton, Abbott Lawrence and Amos Lawrence among the shareholders. The same article's background section gives 1819 as the year the bank was founded.

The notes were the problem. William Graham Sumner, in his History of Banking in the United States, quotes a passage saying country bank money was bought in Boston at a discount and put back into circulation at face value, and that brokers sometimes carried notes home to the issuing banks for redemption. A committee of the Suffolk Bank reported on February 24, 1819, that it was expedient to receive the foreign money the New England Bank already received. Sumner adds that any bank willing to make a permanent deposit of $5,000 would get its own bills back at the same discount at which they were purchased, and that bills of banks refusing a deposit would be sent home for payment.

The 1824 plan went further. Sumner says the associated banks contributed $300,000 in their notes, in proportion to their capital, to a fund for taking up the foreign notes, redeeming them and sending them home; specie replaced the fund. He dates the business to May 24, 1824. Wikipedia says only that, starting in 1824, it and six other banks created the arrangement, and the 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica says the Suffolk system came into operation in 1824. The Britannica adds that the New England Bank was the pioneer of the movement, in 1814.

Country banks did not welcome it. Sumner says they felt their circulation would shrink and that they would need a larger specie reserve, and that in derision they called the associated banks the "Holy Alliance" and the Suffolk the "Six Tailed Bashaw." A convention of country bank stockholders met at Boston on January 16, 1826, to organize a counter-alliance, in Sumner's account.

By Sumner's description, the working arrangement within two years was this: each bank placed a permanent deposit of $2,000 and upward with the bank, free of interest, and in return the Suffolk Bank redeemed the bills of that bank that came to it from any source. The Suffolk Bank reserved the right to send bills home for specie redemption, and credited New England bills in good standing at par on the day after receipt. Wikipedia gives the same $2,000 starting deposit and the one-business-day credit. The New International Encyclopaedia calls the plan an arrangement making it the channel through which New England banks' notes reaching Boston were forwarded to their issuers, so that sound banks found it in their interest to keep a redemption fund there.

The scale grew. Wikipedia says that by 1838 over 300 banks, basically all of New England's, redeemed their notes through the Suffolk System. Sumner reports that the Suffolk Bank handled average daily redemptions of about $750,000 in 1850, and says that in 1854 the redemption department employed seventy clerks. The 1911 Britannica puts the 1858 figures at New England circulation of less than $40,000,000 against redemptions through the bank of $400,000,000 in that year.

The sources disagree about what the system was for. Wikipedia reports that Murray Rothbard credited it with a stabilizing influence on the New England economy, while some historians think its aim was to monopolize the brokerage of country bank notes and so decrease circulation. Sumner judges that its great gains came from the ignorance of country bankers who were over-issuing, and says it did not really keep them sound. Wikipedia also records the phrase "a good regulator of a bad system."

The end came in 1858. Sumner says the country banks obtained a charter in 1855 for the Bank of Mutual Redemption, a cooperative association of themselves, which went into operation in 1858. The Suffolk Bank published a notice that it would not continue the system after November 30, and after some friction the redemption business was divided between the two banks, according to Sumner. Wikipedia says the Bank of Mutual Redemption then assumed the role for New England.

The Suffolk Bank itself outlasted the system. After the National Bank Act of 1864, Wikipedia says, it was reorganized as the Suffolk National Bank on January 1, 1865. It merged in 1902 with the Washington National Bank to form the National Suffolk Bank, which was liquidated in 1903.

The Question

Before 1858, what did Boston's Suffolk Bank do for New England banks that kept a standing deposit with it?

Show the answer

The Answer

It redeemed their banknotes at face value. Banks with a permanent deposit had their notes taken at par, and the Suffolk Bank reserved the right to send bills home for specie.

Send this question to a friend

Read next

By clicking “Send me a stumper” you agree to Money Stumper’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.