The Medici Bank: how a Florentine house made money from paper slips
The Medici Bank was a financial institution created by the Medici family in Italy and run from 1397 to 1494, according to Wikipedia, which calls it the largest and most respected bank in Europe in its prime. Its everyday product was not a loan or a savings account. It was a handwritten slip of paper, and the reason the bank sold it that way came from a rule of the Church.
The founder was Giovanni di Bicci de' Medici. Wikipedia says the bank's founding is usually dated to 1397, when Giovanni separated his bank from his nephew Averardo's bank, which had effectively been acting as a branch in Rome, and moved his small bank from Rome to Florence. He and a partner raised 10,000 gold florins to begin operating. The sources differ on the timing. The separate Wikipedia article on Giovanni says his uncle Vieri de' Medici retired in 1393, leaving the bank in Giovanni's hands, and that it grew vastly and quickly from there. The 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica credits Giovanni with establishing banks in Italy and abroad, and says the Council of Constance, held from 1414 to 1418, enabled him to realize enormous profits.
The Church's rule shaped the Medici Bank. Wikipedia says usury was still banned in this period, under an interpretation summed up in Latin as "Whatever exceeds the principal is usury." A bank could not openly promise interest to depositors, so the Medici Bank made most of its money by selling bills of exchange. A bill certified that a person had paid a Medici branch a sum, and told another branch to pay it back in local currency at the exchange rate fixed when the bill was bought. The gap between issue and payment, set by custom, was called usance. Wikipedia gives three months as the usance between Florence and London. Because the exchange rate could move in either direction in the meantime, the arrangement carried risk, and Wikipedia says that risk kept it from being usury, except in the case of "dry exchange," where the movement of money was fictitious.
The bank's structure was as unusual as its product. Wikipedia describes a single partnership in Florence that held the lion's share of each branch, with every branch incorporated as its own partnership, and says it resembles a modern holding company. Each partnership was dissolved at the end of the year on March 24, and the books were checked and profits reckoned. Branch managers drew no salary. They were treated as having invested a sum greater than they actually had, so they shared in the profits. Wikipedia names branches in Venice, Geneva, which moved to Lyon in 1466, Avignon, Bruges, London, Pisa and Milan, plus an itinerant branch that followed the Pope. The papal connection was the engine. Wikipedia says that in 1427 the Roman branch held approximately 100,000 florins on deposit from the Papal Curia, while the capitalization of the entire bank was only about 25,000 gold florins. The 1911 Britannica adds that after Nicholas V became Pope, he employed the Medici bank in Rome in all the affairs of the curia. Wikipedia reports that Rome supplied as much as 62 percent of the profits between 1420 and 1435. Giovanni died in 1429, and according to Lorenzo his fortune was worth around 180,000 gold florins. His son Cosimo took over, and Wikipedia calls 1435 to 1455 the bank's most profitable period.
Then came the losses. Wikipedia says the London branch lent heavily to Edward IV, who owed 10,500 pounds sterling when an auditor looked in 1467, and that the Wars of the Roses left him unable to repay. London finished its liquidation in 1478 with total losses of 51,533 gold florins. The Bruges branch, run by Tommaso Portinari, lent far beyond its partnership terms, which capped loans at 6,000 pounds groat. Wikipedia says upwards of 70,000 gold florins were lost across London and Bruges, and quotes Lorenzo the Magnificent: "These are the great profits which are accruing to us through the management of Tommaso Portinari."
Historians do not agree on the cause of the decline. Wikipedia says de Roover attributes its beginning to Cosimo, who spent most of his time on politics and patronage and left little room for choosing branch managers or watching for fraud. Wikipedia also cites a drift in gold against silver between 1475 and 1485. Richard Goldthwaite, writing in 1987, calls those economic conditions inadequately explained and says the contraction under Lorenzo was due simply to bad management, with politics always taking priority over business. Machiavelli, quoted by Wikipedia, said the managers had been given such a loose rein that they began to act like princes rather than merchants. Wikipedia also notes that Florentine banks commonly kept as little as 5 percent of deposits in reserve, which meant trouble could arrive suddenly.
The end came through politics. When King Charles VIII of France invaded Italy in 1494, Piero di Lorenzo de' Medici conceded to Charles and to the impending insolvency of the bank. Wikipedia says the remaining assets and records were seized and distributed to creditors, all the branches were declared dissolved, and a mob burned the central Florentine bank. Even then, it says, the Medici Bank was the biggest in Europe.
Little paper survives to check any of this. Wikipedia says no balance sheets have survived, and only a few pages of some account books escaped a frenzied mob. What remains is partnership agreements, correspondence and account-book fragments.
- Wikipedia, Medici Bank — en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia, Giovanni di Bicci de' Medici — en.wikipedia.org
- 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica, Medici (Wikisource) — en.wikisource.org